Entry #282

1-5 How I vote on audio..and the meanings behind it. (Redone)

2015-07-01 03:18:17 by wyldfyre1
Updated

 

           

Alright, Well since I wrote the original the voting system changed so I think i will better explain how I review in this new system. There's not much difference but for those of you who are new and are unused to how I review here you go:

 

A Quick Note

Let me first start out with this. Know what I am rather strict with music. If I have given you a vote that you don't think is fair it has nothing to do with you personally, or your friends, or your dog. Its the vote I felt the song deserved. I usually will tell you in the review what I feel you can improve on or even fix. Know this: I AM BIG ON ORIGINALITY. If the song is not original and or is a ripped from a midi then expect a negative review. Your response to my reviews is up to you (I'm generally pretty nice even when negative) so if you want to argue just know this - You are posting music on a site that gives people the option to comment. You knew this when you posted it. If you cannot accept constructive critiquing then it will reflect upon you- My views do not reflect upon if we are friends, or otherwise. Expect an honest review.

I go by one general rule: Music is emotion.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

How Wyldfyre1 reviews audio

 

 

No Star / half a Star - Horrid. I will most likely give you a list of things that I feel need improvement.

Full Star / Star and a half - There were portions of the audio I enjoyed but the majority of the music needed work.

Two Stars / Two and a half stars - There was something in the song that got my feet tapping but it most likely felt as if it was missing something.

Three Stars / Three and a half stars - I enjoyed the song a bit more than most. I see small room for improvement.

Four Stars / Four and a half stars - This song is near perfect. I'm rather impressed by the music. It probably just needed that extra OOMPH.

Five stars - The perfect song in my opinion. The song blew my mind.

 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

Thanks for reading and if you want me to review your music or just want to leave some love feel free to post below with a link for music.

 

as always much love to all the newgrounds audio people out there

 

Wyldfyre1


Comments

You must be logged in to comment on this post.


Dj-GonzoDj-Gonzo

2015-07-01 04:34:23

Hi! I've read your post and I think you could help me by reviewing some of my songs or telling what can I improve if you have time. Thanks in advance!

http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/631622

http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/625298

Also if you like my work, follow me to keep updated!

>GTB

(Updated ) wyldfyre1 responds:

All done, Had a listen and reviewed.


saucybirdsaucybird

2015-07-01 12:04:05

This is fantastic. Regardless if you hate it, I'd love a genuine person to review this if you'd like to:

http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/631899

wyldfyre1 responds:

done =)


TroisnyxTroisnyx

2015-07-03 05:45:03

How would you rate teasers or unfinished pieces?

wyldfyre1 responds:

I guess it depends on how much exactly there is to rate.


Dj-GonzoDj-Gonzo

2015-09-27 12:46:43

Only returning here to say that I finished one of the demos you reviewed, go and check it out and let me know if you see any improvement please :)

--> http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/625298